Welcome to the Gallery – a place where you'll find hope and strength through the healing power of art and the universal reach of technology –
a place where you can
Connect, Create, and Thrive!
Interested in partnering with us?
Click here to find out how!
Displaying (1) Comments | Comment on this piece | Report objectionable art
I agree that his [Steig's] behaviour is apenlpatry duplicitous, but of no particular import IMO. ================curryja | February 9, 2011 at 7:05 am Nick, i haven’t been following this one too closely, i view it as a blogospheric tempest in a teapot. that kind of blogospheric coverage can definitely make you frosty, I personally succumbed a bit during “heretic.” In terms of who wins for politeness on this one, i don’t think either side can claim many points. I don’t really see any meta issues on this one (O’Donnell got a tough review, AMS journals are known for that, the editor was somewhat lax in making the authors jump through hoops based on comments by a reviewer with a conflict of interest, but the paper got published). I mainly found this one of interest in terms of the vehemence of the dispute over not very much, really. Personalities from the chiefdoms of the two tribes having a clash.===============RobB | February 9, 2011 at 7:11 am Fair enough, Judith, but what about the accusation that Steig anonymously insisted on changes to O’Donnell et al that he later used to disparage the paper? That must contravene professional standards (if they exist?) Or is the matter also just part of the tribal hurley burley?=======================curryja | February 9, 2011 at 7:17 am I agree that his behaviour is apenlpatry duplicitous, but of no particular import IMO.========================dhogaza | February 9, 2011 at 4:12 pm I agree that his behaviour is apenlpatry duplicitous, but of no particular import IMO. Without even bothering to hear Eric’s side of the story …Nice.BTW over at bart’s there’s a fair chunk of the review-response chain reproduced there, and my quick read is that it doesn’t support the claim of duplicity.Eric has stated he’ll post a response soon over at RC.I gotta love how quickly you jump to conclusions without having even read the review-response chain.
By: | Jul 09, 2012 | Report Comment
my first date with lori
jay
teledating at its best
There are 17 pieces of art in this thread